From 11 Seats to 6: What’s Next for New York Republicans

From 11 Seats to 6: What's Next for New York Republicans

Key Points

  • Next year, New York Republicans will hold 6 of the state's 26 House seats, down from 11 in 2022.
  • A proposed state constitutional amendment could let Democrats redraw congressional maps for 2028, putting three more Republican seats at risk.
  • After that, the 2030 census could reduce the size of the New York congressional delegation by one or two seats.

New York Republicans Fall to Six House Seats

For the next two years, New York Republicans will hold just six of the state's 26 House seats. Four years ago, they held eleven.

On Nov. 3, Republicans lost one seat. Democrat Cait Conley beat incumbent Republican Mike Lawler in New York's 17th District by an unofficial 53% to 47%. The district covers all of Rockland County and parts of Westchester and Dutchess counties.

Republicans almost lost another seat. In the North Country, Republican Anthony Constantino won New York's 21st District by just two points, according to unofficial results. Constantino is the Trump-endorsed founder and CEO of Sticker Mule. It was Elise Stefanik's open seat, which she won by 24 points in 2024. Constantino spent $17 million of his own money to win the seat, outspending his Democratic opponent by more than twice.

As well as losing a seat in the New York delegation, Republicans also lost control of the House of Representatives. As of Nov. 17, the Associated Press shows Democrats with 256 seats to 171 for Republicans, with eight seats still undecided.

Six Seats and Falling

The table below shows how New York Republicans went from 11 seats to 6 seats. Republicans won six of 27 seats in 2018 and eight in 2020. They peaked at 11 of 26 in 2022, the first election under a map drawn by a court-appointed special master. That map replaced a Democratic plan that could have given Democrats 22 of 26 seats. The state's highest court struck down the Democratic plan 4-3 in Harkenrider v. Hochul. Rep. Nicholas Langworthy, then the state Republican chairman and the current representative from NY 23, said: "The Hochulmander has officially been defeated."

Election Year Republican Seats Total NY Seats Republican Share
2018 6 27 22%
2020 8 27 30%
2022 11 26 42%
2024 7 26 27%
2026 6 26 23%

Since their high water mark, the number of Republican seats has fallen.

  • Democrat Tom Suozzi won NY-3 on Long Island in a February 2024 special election. The House expelled Republican George Santos, who later went to prison for wire fraud and aggravated identity theft. President Trump commuted his sentence.
  • In November 2024, Democrats flipped three more seats.
    • Laura Gillen beat Rep. Anthony D'Esposito in NY-4.
    • Josh Riley beat Rep. Marc Molinaro in NY-19.
    • John Mannion beat Rep. Brandon Williams in NY-22.

That left Republicans with seven seats. This month, Conley's win over Lawler in NY-17 brought them down to six.

New York Mid-Decade Redistricting in 2028 and What It Means for Republicans

Democrats in the NYS legislature have proposed a constitutional amendment to allow mid-decade redistricting, just like Republican-led states like Texas have done. Democrats say the amendment responds to red states that redrew their congressional maps to favor Republican candidates at President Trump's urging.

Changing the New York State constitution takes several steps. Lawmakers must pass the constitutional amendment in each of two separate years, with an election in between. Then the referendum is placed on the ballot for voters to decide. The governor has no formal role.

New York is between the first and second steps. The Assembly and Senate passed the constitutional amendment on June 3 - step one. Then came the November midterm elections. Now, the Legislature must approve the amendment again in 2027 - step two. If that happens, the referendum can appear on the November 2027 ballot - step three. Democrats will hold two-thirds majorities in both chambers of the New York State legislature when the 2027 session begins. The amendment needs only simple majorities, so they can advance it without Republican votes. But passage is not assured. If voters approve the referendum on the November 2027 ballot, new congressional district lines could be ready for the 2028 election.

One wrinkle - the amendment would temporarily allow the Legislature to redraw congressional districts before the next census-based redistricting. It also removes language that bars congressional districts from favoring parties or incumbents. That would let the Democratic majority enact new lines without Republican votes, subject to legal requirements. This past June, experts told Spectrum News that the amendment could help Democrats gain up to four seats. One of those was the Hudson Valley Lawler seat that Democrats have already won, so any further Democratic gains would come at the expense of the six remaining Republicans.

Democratic targets could include the seats below.

  • One of the two Long Island seats: either NY-1, held by Rep. Nick LaLota, or NY-2, held by Rep. Andrew Garbarino.
  • The Staten Island / Brooklyn seat, NY-11, held by Rep. Nicole Malliotakis.
  • The three upstate seats: NY-21, to be held by Rep.-elect Anthony Constantino, NY-23, held by Rep. Nicholas Langworthy, and NY-24, held by Rep. Claudia Tenney.

But mid-decade redistricting is not a done deal. Gov. Kathy Hochul said the "political landscape has changed." In California, for example, Democrats flipped at least three Republican seats under the new Proposition 50 map. And at least five of the state’s nine Republican House members were among the political casualties. It is unclear whether Democrats would have won those seats under the old district lines. Nationally, Republican redistricting efforts in Texas, Ohio, Florida, North Carolina and Tennessee targeted 12 Democratic-held seats but flipped only two.

Hochul has not committed to supporting the amendment. Democrats now control the House of Representatives even without NYS midterm redistricting. Hochul plans to speak with House Democratic leader and, likely, new Speaker of the House Hakeem Jeffries, as well as other legislative leaders, before deciding. And NYS Democrats are not completely united although it appears that most are onboard. State Sen. Shelley Mayer, for example, has urged more consideration, while Rochester (NY25) Rep. Joe Morelle, who is likely to be the new chair of the House Committee on Administration, supports moving ahead.

Unsurprisingly, New York Republicans are lining up against mid-decade redistricting, even though President Trump demanded it in red states. Soon-to-be former Rep. Mike Lawler said, "They [Democrats] will do anything in their power to seize power." Former Rep. John Faso called the amendment "a terrible affront to the voters of our state." and noted that NY voters rejected a similar redistricting plan in 2021.

New York's Congressional Delegation Could Shrink After the 2030 Census

What will happen to the New York congressional delegation after the 2030 census? The Brennan Center estimates that New York will lose two congressional seats after the 2030 census, falling from 26 to 24. But redistricting expert Jonathan Cervas projects a loss of only one seat, leaving New York with 25.

But there's another wrinkle. The Census Bureau has proposed a change in how the census is done. They propose counting only citizens and lawful permanent residents. Critics say the proposed change conflicts with the 14th Amendment to the U.S. Constitution which says representatives are apportioned among the states "according to their respective numbers, counting the whole number of persons in each State..." - "persons," not citizens. Regardless, redistricting expert Cervas doesn't think New York would lose any additional seats even with the rule change.

Are New York Republican congressmen a vanishing breed? Not yet. They will still hold six seats in January, down from 11 seats just four years ago. And if the redistricting amendment is successful, after likely Republican court challenges, a new 2028 congressional map could reduce the number of NYS Republican congressmen even more.

Related from WNYP

Get WNYP in Your Inbox

Independent, ad-free political accountability for Western New York. Subscribe free.

Sources

  1. Associated Press, 2026 U.S. House results as of Nov. 16, 2026
  2. Federal Election Commission filings, Anthony Constantino for Congress (candidate contributions and loans)
  3. New York State Senate, Bill S10637-A (redistricting constitutional amendment), passed June 3, 2026
  4. Spectrum News, experts on the amendment's potential Democratic gains (June 2026)
  5. LangworthyWatch.org
  6. Harkenrider v. Hochul, New York Court of Appeals (2022)
  7. Brennan Center for Justice, 2030 apportionment projection
  8. Jonathan Cervas, 2030 apportionment and citizen-only counting analysis
  9. U.S. Census Bureau, proposed rule on apportionment residence criteria (Sept. 10, 2026)
  10. Reporting on Hochul, Jeffries, Mayer and Morelle, November 2026
This is a picture of Rep. Langworthy
Blog

Western New York’s Congressional Curse

Please enable JavaScript in your browser to complete this form. Please enable JavaScript in your browser to complete this form. Email * Subscribe Nicholas Langworthy ...

Subscribe to my newsletter for the most recent updates.

Share your email address to get our latest stories delivered straight to your inbox.

This is a picture of Joseph J. Zambon DDS, PhD the author of this post and of the website Western New York Politics

Author: Joseph Zambon

Let me tell you a bit about myself. I’ve lived in Western New York all my life except for four years of active duty in the U.S. Navy toward the end of the Viet Nam War. I served at Portsmouth Naval Hospital, Navy Support Activity LaMaddalena, and Subase New London followed by nearly a decade in both the Navy and Army reserves. I’m a retired UB professor and I’ve lived throughout Western New York including Batavia, Amherst, Williamsville, and East Aurora. 

 

Over the years, I’ve seen numerous political fiascos in Western New York. For example,  the proposed but never built Peace Bridge span; ending tolls on the NYS Thruway;  and, financial debacles that led (and may soon lead again) to the Erie County Fiscal Stability Authority and the Buffalo Fiscal Stability Authority.  And on and on.

 

Leadership matters. Competence is more important than appearance. Elections have consequences.

Scroll to Top