westernnypolitics

Western New York Politics

News and Opinion on Politics in Western New York and Elsewhere

2022-24 WNY Cong. District map
2022-24 WNY Cong. District map

New York’s Balance of Payments: New York’s Tax Money Subsidizes Other States

A picture of money changing hands.

The Rockefeller Institute of Government’s 7th annual analysis of Federal funding reveals a dramatic shift in New York’s balance of payments (BOP) for Federal Fiscal Year (FFY) 2022. It got much worse.

The balance of payments between states, like between nations, measures winners and losers. The losers are the states that give more to the federal government than they receive back. The winners are the states that receive more from the federal government than they send. 

After two years of winning due to COVID-19 relief spending, New York returned to its pre-pandemic position as a net subsidizer (loser) of other states. New York’s money goes to subsidize other states rather than coming back to New York.

Here’s a breakdown of the Rockefeller Institute report’s key findings and implications for New York and the nation.

 

Key Findings

  • New York’s 2022 Balance of Payments:
    • New York had a net negative balance of 19.4 billion, which means it sent 19.4 billion more money to the federal government than it received in 2022.
    • New York’s ranking, from states that got the most (net recipients) to states that lost the most (net contributors) to the federal budget, dropped from 5th most favorable in 2021 to 46th in 2022
    • 46th is just 4 spots above its pre-pandemic position when it was the worst in the nation. Worst, meaning New York had the largest negative balance of payments.  
  • COVID-19 Spending Impact:
    • Federal emergency spending during the pandemic was a more equitable distribution of federal aid. It benefited populous states like New York, California, and Texas. Less populous states didn’t get less than before but more populous states got more than pre-pandemic.
    • However, in 2022, COVID-19 relief spending ended, and federal funding to states returned to what it was before the pandemic.
This is the state's balance of payments as determined by the Rockefeller Institute

National Comparisons:

These states have the Least Favorable balance of payments in 2022. They send more money to the federal government than they get back

  1. California (-$72.0 billion)
  2. Massachusetts (-$30.0 billion)
  3. Washington (-$22.5 billion)
  4. New Jersey (-$19.4 billion)
  5. New York (-$19.4 billion)

These states have the Most Favorable balance of payments.  They get back more money from the federal government than they send.

  1. Virginia ($129.2 billion)
  2. Maryland ($71.6 billion)
  3. Kentucky ($65.4 billion)
  4. Ohio ($56.7 billion)
  5. North Carolina ($52.7 billion)

These lists show just the top five in each category. Most states are net recipients, that is, winners.  There are only about 11 states that are losers in this game. They get back much less than they send to the federal government and were listed in my previous post.  They are Illinois, Utah, New York, Colorado, Connecticut, Minnesota, New Hampshire, California, Washington, New Jersey, and Massachusetts.

 

Per Capita Analysis

    • New York’s per capita balance of payments dropped in 2022 with the end of COVID relief money.
    • It fell from a net positive $7,750 and $6,178 in 2020 and 2021, respectively, to a net negative $984 in 2022
    • That’s -$984 for each person in New York compared to the national average of +$2,799.
    • Between 2020 and 2022, that is a swing of about $8,750.
    • The state’s excess burden (the difference between its per capita balance of payments and the national average) is the largest in the history of the analysis.

 

What Drove the Shift From Positive to Negative? Where Did New York’s Money Go?

  1. Pandemic Relief Wind-Down:
    • Federal COVID-19 spending in 2020 and 2021 greatly benefited New York and other large states due to its population size and level of need.
    • As emergency COVID spending decreased in 2022, New York’s share of Federal expenditures shrank and went back to before the COVID pandemic.
  2. Economic Recovery:
    • When COVID-19 vaccines became widely available,  the economy recovered. Federal spending shifted away from emergency COVID relief.
    • That shift in federal spending reduced the yearly federal budget deficit by $1.4 trillion in 2022 but to the detriment of states like New York
  3. Wealth Concentration:
    • New York’s negative balance of payments is also due to the fact that there are a few very wealthy people in New York. They pay a lot of federal taxes but receive less in return than other states.

 

Implications for New York

  • Net Subsidizer Role: New York’s return to its pre-pandemic position means it contributes more to the federal government than it returns.
  • Policy Considerations: The Rockefeller Institute report should inform policymakers that they must evaluate the consequences of fiscal decisions, particularly for states like New York that bear an unfairly large share of the Federal tax burden.
  • Strategies.  New York could implement several strategies to minimize the negative balance of payments. I’ll discuss those strategies in a future blog.

 

Looking Ahead

The 2022 data signals a return to “business as usual” for U.S. fiscal policy and New York’s balance of payments. While pandemic-era relief programs provided temporary equity, the winding down of emergency spending has reignited debates about the fairness of Federal funding distribution.

The question is, why do a few states continually subsidize other states? With few exceptions, why does federal policy require that predominantly blue states subsidize predominantly red states?

Previous Posts

Western New York Republicans Nicholas Langworthy and Claudia Tenney Back Anti-DEI Efforts and Hurt Local Veterans in the Process

Veterans are Casualties in the Republican Culture Wars How DEI Programs Help Veterans Most people have heard negative things about Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion (DEI) programs, especially from Republicans who call them “woke” or unnecessary. But what many don’t realize is that DEI programs also help military veterans. Republican Representatives

Read More »

A Rough Night for Langworthy: Voter Anger on Telephone Town Hall

Angry Constituents Confront Rep. Nicholas Langworthy in Heated Telephone Town Hall Representative Nicholas Langworthy (R-NY23) held one of his periodic telephone town halls, and the mood among his constituents was not good. The anger and frustration from callers were palpable, reaching a level of intensity that longtime observers of Langworthy’s

Read More »

Voter ID Takes Center Stage During Trump’s Disaster Tour 

President Trump with the First Lady and Governor Hawley in Asheville, NC President Donald J. Trump underscored what he believes is the need for voter ID laws during the first stop of his disaster assessment tour in North Carolina and California. Speaking on the tarmac in Asheville, North Carolina, alongside

Read More »

Republicans’ Budget Reconciliation Proposals Threaten New Yorkers

Targeting Key Programs and Policies One of the most controversial Republican budget reconciliation proposals involves reversing key provisions of the Inflation Reduction Act (IRA), particularly those aimed at lowering prescription drug prices. The IRA, signed into law in 2022, was designed to save Medicare an estimated $20 billion over ten

Read More »

Republican Speaker Johnson Forces House Republicans to Nominate President and Convicted Felon Donald J. Trump for the Nobel Peace Prize

Speaker Johnson’s Directive Following the orders of President and Convicted Felon Donald J. Trump, the Republican Party is organizing another effort to get President Trump the Nobel Peace Prize. Consequently, Speaker of the House Michael Johnson ordered all Republican members of Congress to submit letters to the Nobel Peace Prize

Read More »

Is Rep. Claudia Tenney (R-NY24) the New Face of Voter Suppression?

Rep. Claudia Tenney R-NY24, New Co-Chair of the House Election Integrity Caucus Tenney is the New Co-Chair of the House Election Integrity Caucus Rep. Claudia Tenney is the Republican congresswoman representing the New York State counties surrounding Lake Ontario. She has recently stepped into the national spotlight as co-chair of

Read More »

Why Doesn’t Langworthy (R-NY23) Fight for His District?

President-Elect Trump with his good friend Rep. Nicholas Langworthy (R-NY23) In his December 29, 2024 email to constituents, Rep. Nicholas Langworthy (R-NY23) attempted to trumpet his first-term accomplishments representing Western New York and the Southern Tier. Langworthy proclaimed, “For the fiscal year 2024, I helped secure $22.2 million for 14

Read More »

What the Frank? Politicians Abusing the Franking System and Violating Campaign Finance Laws?

Taxpayer-Funded Campaigning: How Congress Exploits Franking Privileges Congressional franking privileges—a policy originally intended to facilitate non-partisan communication between lawmakers and their constituents—have devolved into a mechanism for incumbents to promote themselves at taxpayer expense. Whenever the message “Paid for by official funds authorized by the House of Representatives” appears at

Read More »

Reps. Langworthy (R-NY23) and Tenney (R-NY24) Voted to Cover Up Gaetz’s Dirty Laundry – But the Truth Is Out, and It’s Ugly!

Republican Rep. Nicholas Langworthy (NY23) Rep. Claudia Tenney R-NY24 Voted to Hide Gaetz’ Secrets Western New York Representative Nicholas Langworthy (R-NY23), representing the Southern Tier and Western New York, and Representative Claudia Tenney (R-NY24), representing counties around Lake Ontario, voted a couple of weeks ago against releasing the House Ethics

Read More »

Republican Congressman Nicholas Langworthy (NY23) Votes for a Continuing Resolution Without Funding for Pediatric Cancer Research or 9/11 First Responder Healthcare

New York’s 23rd Congressional District Representative Nick Langworthy Langworthy’s Sunday Night Missive Republican Nicholas Langworthy, who represents New York’s 23rd Congressional District, which covers the Southern Tier and Western New York, sends weekly email updates to his constituents nearly every Sunday night. These updates typically outline his recent activities but

Read More »

Republican Congressman Nicholas Langworthy is Guilty of “Political Malpractice,” According to President-Elect Donald Trump

In January, Republicans will control the Presidency, the Senate, the House, and the Supreme Court. You’d think that would make any autocrat happy! But, perhaps unsurprisingly, the Republicans are starting to turn against one another. President-elect Trump recently posted messages on his social media platform, Truth Social, that should make

Read More »

How the GOP Might Help Trump Stick Around for a Third Term

President-elect Trump is not exactly known for following the rules. He even admitted it was a “mistake” to leave the White House after losing the 2020 election. Now that he’s about to return to the Oval Office, he won’t pack his bags again, certainly not after another four-year term. The

Read More »

Dark Times for Dental Health

Summary Robert Kennedy Jr. is Trump’s nominee to lead the nation’s healthcare agencies. He is unqualified. Kennedy is a conspiracy theorist, anti-vaxxer, and anti-fluoridationist. He spreads lies and misinformation. Vaccines have saved hundreds of millions of lives. Smallpox vaccines combined with an intense global public health effort eradicated smallpox from

Read More »

Rep. Nicholas Langworthy (R-NY23) is an Election Denier and Rep. Claudia Tenney (R-NY24) is an Election Skeptic

From Electiondenier.com website Election Deniers Among the New York Congressional Delegation Data from https://electiondeniers.org/ lists three Republicans among the 26-member New York congressional delegation as “Election Deniers.” The three are (1) Nicole Malliotakis, R-NY11, representing Staten Island; (2) Elise Stefanik, R-NY21, representing northern rural counties; and (3) Nicholas Langworthy, R-NY23,

Read More »

Fact-Checking Rep. Nicholas Langworthy: “I’m Unfamiliar with Project 2025”

Liar, Liar, Pants on Fire During the NY23 congressional debate between Democratic candidate Thomas Carle and Republican incumbent Nicholas Langworthy,  the contentious issue of Project 2025 took center stage. Project 2025, The Presidential Transition Project, formally titled the “Mandate for Leadership: The Conservative Promise” is publicly accessible and available for anyone

Read More »

Fact-Checking Rep. Langworthy (R-NY23): His Support for Infrastructure Claim

Former President Trump and Rep. Langworthy R-NY23 Nick Langworthy recently wrote on X (formerly Twitter), “I’m proud to champion policies [such as] investing in infrastructure that supports our communities.” But here’s the fact-check: his statement distorts his and his party’s record on infrastructure. House Republicans Overwhelmingly Opposed the Infrastructure Act

Read More »

Couches, Cats, and Campaigns: J.D. Vance and Chris LaCivita’s Plan to Win North Carolina’s Electoral Votes

The False Story Suggesting JD Vance’s Relationship With an Upholstered Couch J.D. Vance and Chris LaCivita teamed up to orchestrate what might be the weirdest campaign strategy of this election cycle. Combining Vance’s alleged upholstery obsession with LaCivita’s evil political wizardry, they’re strategizing to win North Carolina’s 16 electoral votes.

Read More »

NY Republicans Langworthy, Tenney, and Williams Endorse Voter Suppression Bill

On the evening of September 18, 2024, Representatives Langworthy (R-NY23), Tenney (R-NY24), and Williams (R-NY22) cast votes assaulting Americans’ right to vote. These representatives voted in favor of H.R.9494, the “Continuing Appropriations and Other Matters Act, 2025.” Buried within this bill’s deceptively labeled “Other Matters” was the SAVE Act, a

Read More »

NY24 Rep. Claudia Tenney’s “Broken Moral Compass”

Former President Trump with Rep. Tenney (R-NY24) After the 2022 assault on Paul Pelosi, the husband of Speaker of the House Nancy Pelosi, the far-right MAGA faction, including Rep. Claudia Tenney, callously mocked this violent attack on an older man. As the Buffalo News remarked about her before this incident,

Read More »

NY24 Congressional District Representative: Claudia Tenney

Who is Claudia Tenney? 1961 born in New Harford, NY; parents Cynthia and John R. Tenney, New York State Supreme Court Justice, one of five siblings  1983 B.A. Colgate University  1987 J.D. University of Cincinnati Co-owner of a commercial printing and manufacturing company in Sherburne, NY, started by her grandfather

Read More »

NY Congressional Delegation Vote on the $95 Billion Foreign Aid Package

Foreign aid is a contentious issue in American politics, often sparking debates over national interests, fiscal responsibility, and global humanitarian efforts. The recent passage of a $95 billion aid package, including support for Israel, Ukraine, and Taiwan, highlights the complexities in navigating partisan divides and policy disagreements.  Speaker Johnson split

Read More »

Republican Dirty Tricks in the 2024 Campaign

I’m interested in the mechanics of political campaigns, especially the more aggressive strategies like negative campaigning and dirty tricks. Though often confused, these tactics serve distinct purposes. Negative campaigning, such as attack ads, is based on verifiable facts presented in a way that damages the opponent’s election prospects. In contrast,

Read More »

Trump Campaign’s Disgraceful Acts at Arlington National Cemetery

Trump Campaign Crosses the Line at Arlington National Cemetery: Disrespect and Law Violations Spark Outrage Arlington National Cemetery is more than a cemetery; it symbolizes the sacrifices made by American service members. The sanctity of this hallowed place is preserved through federal laws and strict rules designed to maintain an

Read More »

Find Your NYS Assemblyman and Their Contact Information

Locate Your New York State Assemblyman or Assemblywoman Click on the green square that matches your assembly district, and you’ll be directed to a new webpage. This will take you straight to the New York State legislator page of the representative for that district. 133 134 135 Add Your Tooltip

Read More »

Why Won’t Our Representatives Fight For Lower Prescription Drug Prices?

Rep. Brandon Williams R-NY22 Rep. Nick Langworthy (R-NY23) Rep. Claudia Tenney R-NY24 Williams, Langworthy, and Tenney are MAGA Republicans representing Western and Central New York. None support lowering prescription drug prices for their constituents. Guess which one actually voted against lowering drug prices? For years, Americans have struggled with the

Read More »

When Did Military Service Become a Political Liability?

Throughout American history, military service was not just an asset but almost a prerequisite for political success. Serving in the armed forces imbued candidates with a sense of duty, patriotism, and leadership – qualities that resonated deeply with the electorate. However, the evolution of media, political strategies, and societal values

Read More »

Financing Western New York Congressional Elections

Rep. Brandon Williams R-NY22 Rep. Nick Langworthy R-NY23 Rep. Claudia Tenney R-NY24 Rep. Joe Morelle D-NY25 Rep. Tim Kennedy D-NY26 Summary NY22 – Williams (R-I) vs Mannion (D) – Lean Democrat – Winner: ??? NY23 – Langworthy (R-I) vs Carle (D) – Solid Republican – Winner: Langworthy NY24 – Tenney

Read More »

Rep. Langworthy’s Latest Sunday Night Diatribe

Radical Right MAGA Republican, Congressman Nick Langworthy (NY-23) Summary Congressman Nick Langworthy released his weekly letter to constituents on 7/28/24. He describes his questioning of the Secret Service Director during the Oversight and Accountability Committee hearings, which led to her resignation. He described introducing legislation to withdraw student visas for

Read More »

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.