Marjorie Taylor Greene Fails to Oust Speaker Johnson

MTG picture

New York Congressional Delegation Vote to Table the Motion to Remove the Speaker of the House of Representatives

Speaker Mike Johnson easily defeated (May 8, 2024) an effort by Representative Marjorie Taylor Greene (R-GA) to remove him from the speakership. Democrats joined with most Republicans to prevent hard-line GOP members from removing their second party leader within a year. 

The vote to table the motion to declare the Office of Speaker of the House of Representatives to be vacant, took less than two minutes and resulted in a decisive 359 “yea” to 43 “nay”, with seven members voting “present.”

Democrats overwhelmingly supported Mr. Johnson.  Historically, the minority party in the House has not supported the opposing party’s speaker. When Kevin McCarthy, the last Republican speaker, was up for removal, Democrats collectively voted to proceed with the motion, leading to his removal from speaker.  He resigned his seat in the House a few weeks later.

The New York delegation voted 21-5 to keep Johnson as Speaker.  The only “Nay” votes came from Velazquez (NY7), Clarke (NY(), Ocasio_Cortez (NY14), Bowman (NY16), and Ryan (NY18).  All the representatives from Western New York – Langworthy, Tenney, Morelle, and Kennedy – voted for the motion to table and to retain Johnson as Speaker.  

H. R.1209 Declaring the Office of Speaker of the House of Representatives to be Vacant

Vote Question: On Motion to Table

House Vote
Yea: 359     
Nay: 43     Present: 7    Not Voting: 21

New York Delegation Vote

Yea 21     Nay 5 

Western New York Delegation

Yea 4     Nay 0

Member

Party

District

Vote

LaLota

R

1

YEA

Garbarino

R

2

YEA

Suozzi

D

3

YEA

D’Esposito

R

4

YEA

Meeks

D

5

YEA

Meng

D

6

YEA

Velázquez

D

7

NAY

Jeffries

D

8

YEA

Clarke

D

9

NAY

Goldman

D

10

YEA

Malliotakis

R

11

YEA

Nadler

D

12

YEA

Espaillat

D

13

YEA

Ocasio-Cortez

D

14

NAY

Torres

D

15

YEA

Bowman

D

16

NAY

Lawler

R

17

YEA

Ryan

D

18

NAY

Molinaro

R

19

YEA

Tonko

D

20

YEA

Stefanik

R

21

YEA

Williams

R

22

YEA

Langworthy

R

23

YEA

Tenney

R

24

YEA

Morelle

D

25

YEA

Kennedy

D

26

YEA

Blog

Rep. Langworthy (R-NY23) Loses on Aviation Bill and Voter Criticism

Key PointsAviation bill failed: Langworthy voted yes on the ROTOR Act to prevent midair collisions, but the bill did not pass after the Pentagon opposed ...

Subscribe to my newsletter for the most recent updates.

Share your email address to get our latest stories delivered straight to your inbox.

This is a picture of Joseph J. Zambon DDS, PhD the author of this post and of the website Western New York Politics

Author: Joseph Zambon

Let me tell you a bit about myself. I’ve lived in Western New York all my life except for four years of active duty in the U.S. Navy toward the end of the Viet Nam War. I served at Portsmouth Naval Hospital, Navy Support Activity LaMaddalena, and Subase New London followed by nearly a decade in both the Navy and Army reserves. I’m a retired UB professor and I’ve lived throughout Western New York including Batavia, Amherst, Williamsville, and East Aurora. 

 

Over the years, I’ve seen numerous political fiascos in Western New York. For example,  the proposed but never built Peace Bridge span; ending tolls on the NYS Thruway;  and, financial debacles that led (and may soon lead again) to the Erie County Fiscal Stability Authority and the Buffalo Fiscal Stability Authority.  And on and on.

 

Leadership matters. Competence is more important than appearance. Elections have consequences.

Scroll to Top